This post and task was written and created by both Jon Orr and Kyle Pearce.
For about a year now Kyle Pearce and I have been travelling to schools and districts across North America sharing our techniques on how to Make Math Moments That Matter for our students.
In those live workshops we’ve been using a task without a name. On the first anniversary after creating that task we wanted to share it here with you and give it a name.
We’re all about creating tasks and then thinking about how they might be modified for use across a variety of grade levels. With a few modifications, you can successfully run this task in classrooms from K through 10. In particular, you could address the following expectations:
- building estimation skills;
- building multiplicative thinking and proportional reasoning using arrays;
- building multiplicative thinking and proportional reasoning using double number lines;
- making connections to the inverse relationship between multiplication and division;
- connecting double number lines and ratio tables to creating and solving proportions through algebraic reasoning;
- highlighting the value of the constant of proportionality (i.e.: unit rates) so students can “own” every problem possible in a proportional relationship;
- determining rates of change;
- representing linear relations in various ways;
- solving problems using the four representations of linear relations; and,
- many more.
Here is Chocolate Mania:
Act 1: Sparking Curiosity
Ask students to create a notice/wonder table or you can use one that we built for our online workshop Making Math Moments That Matter.
Ask your students to write down anything they notice and anything they wonder while viewing this video:
Note: There is no audio. Can’t see the video because you’re viewing this post in a rss reader? Click here to go to the post page.
Here are possible notice and wonders from our workshop participants and also some from our students:
- They’re both wearing plaid.
- The video is in reverse.
- How many chocolates will they eat?
- Did they get sick?
- How long did it take to eat all the chocolate?
- It looks like they’re spitting it out.
- Kyle is eating Kisses.
At this point the students’ responses are listed on the board during the class discussion.
After capturing all the notice and wonders on the board steer the class to working on the problem:
“How many chocolate did Kyle eat? How many did Jon eat?”
Have your students estimate how many each of us ate. What is too high? What is too low? Your students may be feeling uneasy about their estimates; that’s okay! The point here is we don’t have enough information. To help with estimates at this stage we disclose that all the wrappers of all the chocolates we ate are showing in the image above.
We encourage you to record many of the estimates in a chart as a class. This will put some pressure on making those estimates carefully.
Act 2: Revealing Information to Fuel Sense-Making
To avoid rushing to the algorithm we’ll push down the curiosity path some more. Instead of just handing over all the necessary information to solve a problem ask the students what they want to know more about. This process is key; student anticipation of what is needed is a gold mine for understanding where they are in their thinking. By having them ask for information they have to start problem solving!
Students may ask for the time it takes for the whole video and you as the teacher can then say, “And what would you do with that if I gave it to you?” Listen to how they answer this. You’ll gain valuable information about where that student is on this problem solving journey. You will know after that answer if the student is thinking proportionally or not.
Here is some information to share:
Ask students to share what this series of photos tells them. What do they notice? What do they wonder? Then share this photo. It reveals the total amount of ml each of us consumed.
At this point students will have enough information to determine how many pieces of chocolate each of us ate. Let them go at it!
Fuel Sense-Making to Consolidate Learning.
Note: You or your students may want to work with more familiar numbers compared to what you see above. For example, to get a close prediction to the actual number of chocolates each of us ate a student may round the 111.8 ml to 110 ml and similarly round the 17 ml for 3 chocolates to 20 ml.
Depending on the grade level or skill level of your students we can expect to see some of these strategies
- Counting with familiar numbers;
- Using arrays;
- Number line counting;
- Tables of value counting;
- Long division;
- Unit rates;
- Solving Proportions;
- Creating and solving equations.
Here are some of those strategies:
Counting Up Chocolates and ml.
Students may count up 17 ml every 3 pumpkins until they reach close to the total amount of ml. If they go over the total amount they may want to subtract a cup of chocolates so they can get more accurate.
Here’s that strategy in action
Working with Fractions:
To get more precise answers we can encourage students to work with parts of chocolates in decimals or fractions. Many teachers would be inclined to stay away from fractions because they feel it may “de-rail” the lesson. We say use this context to reinforce fraction work and understanding.
Counting/Multiplying/Dividing Using Arrays:
Students may organize their counting strategy in a double array model. Simultaneously counting in groups of 3 pumpkins and 17 ml will allow them to see that they will need just over 6 cups of pumpkins, while showing the proportional relationship between the pumpkins and volume.
Double Number Line:
Students who solve the problem with a proportion will benefit from seeing it laid out on a double number line. By showing how to solve a proportion on a double number line we take a familiar concept (counting on the number line) and extend it to work multiplicatively. Students who solved the problem with an additive strategy will see the benefit of greater precision of using a scale factor.
Many students may use a unit rate to help solve this problem.
Note: This student will benefit from a conversation on notation, units and order of division.
You may choose to use this problem to either introduce or practice linear relations. I used this task to link the idea of finding the unit rate to determining the rate of change (slope) in a linear relation and then use it to build an equation to help solve the problem.
Reveal the Answer:
After consolidating the learning goals you wanted to bring out into the open for discussion with your class show them this reveal video of the actual number of chocolates each of us ate. Be sure to go back and validate those students who estimated the closest early in this task.
Is there a Volume relationship?
We want to leave you with some thinking here. We chose these chocolates for a very specific reason. In fact we hunted down the spherical chocolate that has the same height and diameter of that Hershey’s Kiss.
Your Task: What volume relationships can we pull from this image?
Did you notice the relationship between the amount of chocolate by volume Jon ate versus Kyle?
Look for an upcoming post on how we used this task to teach volume. But before we do that we want to know how you see a lesson on volume forming with this information. Use the comment section below to share your ideas, questions, comments, or even just snippets of what a lesson could look like.